Even though we look around us and see plastic everywhere, in every shape and imaginable application, metals are still a more commonly used raw material in machined products. Metals are the legacy material of choice due to their strength and relative ease of bonding, but advances in polymers are making them useful alternatives for everything from car parts to sports equipment. But higher costs and sometimes volatile substances released during the processing of polymers mean that metals are still the preferred choice of manufacturers for many applications.
Joining metals is the crux of creating assemblies from steel, aluminum, iron or any alloys that need to be brought together in the formation of something greater than the sum of its parts.
The purpose of the proverbial joint (or interface) between materials is to transfer the applied load from one component to the next. A long proven method of joining metals so that the stress distribution is evenly distributed throughout the joint is to weld them.
Mechanical fasteners (bolts or rivets) are still frequently used but using fasteners can add significant weight to a structure. All of the transferred stress is concentrated in the fasteners and the holes through which they pass. To resist fracture, the material must be made thicker and heavier in order to sustain these stress concentrations.
While welding is a great way to make a clean looking joint as opposed to a fastened assembly, it is not without its challenges.
The Art of Arc Welding
Welding techniques fall into two major categories each with their own particular strengths and weaknesses.
Metal Inert Gas welding (or MIG welding) is the most common in manufacturing because it is considered a “semi-automatic” welding process and can incorporate robotics fairly easily. MIG welding works by continuously feeding a spool of metal wire through the torch which melts the wire and fuses it to the metal surface being joined. MIG is a more “point and shoot” approach than the more refined and precise manner of its cousin, Tungsten Inert Gas welding.
To learn more about how to ensure your welding, brazing soldering, cleaning or adhesion process are optimized to create the most reliable products, download our free eBook today: The Manufacturer’s Roadmap to Eliminate Adhesion Issues in Production
Tungsten Inert Gas welding (or TIG welding) requires a highly skilled technician to ensure high quality work because it’s a two-handed operation while also using a pedal to send just the right amount of gas through the torch as well. It can be a slow and meticulous artform in its own right, not merely a means to an end. This isn’t the most practical joining method but it can produce clean, aesthetically pleasing joints and ornamental flourishes if that’s what you’re after.
Regardless of the method employed by manufacturers, there are a lot of aspects of welding that need to be controlled in order to create a strong joint that meets performance expectations. The shield gas needs to have adequate coverage, the temperature and amperage needs to be appropriate for the type of materials being welded, polarity is dialed in, the filler metal is applied properly, and so on.
One concern that can often just get bundled into other things you need to be paying close attention to is the cleanliness of the base and filler materials. When there are contaminants such as oils, grease and oxides on the surface of the metals this makes it nearly impossible to create a strong bond between the molten metal and the base metal.
Why Should You Clean Before Welding?
There are two major failure modes that occur when contaminants are left on the surface of metals being welded.
When contaminants like greases from skin, oils from cutting procedures, or other films get heated by the flame of a welding torch they can volatilize (boil) and get in the way of the molten metals’ ability to flow properly. If the metal doesn’t flow fully or at a controlled rate, voids can be created within the welding bead.
Voids are essentially little air bubbles trapped within the bead that amplify stress put on the seams of the joints. This is called porosity and is usually caused by oxygen, nitrogen and/or hydrogen getting trapped inside the weld. Hydrogen release is most often due to an improperly cleaned surface.
Primer coatings can also be responsible for creating undesirable fumes that may get caught in the weld and wreak havoc on the strength of the joint.
Similarly, another destructive consequence of leaving contaminants on the metal surfaces is an incomplete weld. Some contaminants are neutralized by the heat of the welding torch but if the contaminants require more heat to be removed than what is applied, then the metal may not flow completely over the surface, or will only fuse to a shallow depth. This creates a joint that is brittle and insufficient.
The most common way of testing for both of these failure modes is to test after the welding has occurred, making the validation process expensive and destructive. Grinding out a weld and redoing the job is difficult and the materials are already compromised making it all the harder to create a strong joint on the second or third try. Radiography and ultrasonic inspections, as well as other non-destructive tests, can be used to detect voids or weak welds once the work has been done, but they are reactionary tests and don’t give an indication of what led to the deficient weld. It’s impossible to know if the surface was not clean enough or if another factor was not fully controlled with the torch and metals.
How to Predict a Strong Weld
Contact angle measurements are a useful method of testing the cleanliness of metals before attempting a weld. This method measures the behavior of a drop of liquid on a surface to gauge the surface energy of the material in question. Surface energy is essentially how chemically clean a surface is and if the metal has a high surface energy then the liquid drop will wet out on the surface. The liquid is sensitive to the same microscopic contaminants that the molten metal gets tripped up by. This is an excellent test for welding because the way the droplet flows on the surface gives a clear indication of how the metals will react to each other and whether their flow will be unimpeded.
One of the greatest advantages of contact angle tests is that they are nondestructive and can be done directly on actual parts on the actual production line. The equipment used to take contact angle measurements can be automated so they fit perfectly with any high rate manufacturing process. There are also portable devices that are designed to be used for field inspections when repairs to welded joints are necessary.
To learn more about how to ensure your welding, brazing soldering, cleaning or adhesion process are optimized to create the most reliable products, download our roadmap. This eBook offers a wealth of insight into manufacturing processes and the unforeseen obstacles that engineers face, but don’t have to face alone. Download the free eBook today: The Manufacturer’s Roadmap to Eliminate Adhesion Issues in Production